By Ira Horowitz/By Ann Green

 

Your website can be a great marketing tool, but it can also help your nonprofit raise funds. Learn how to encourage donations on your nonprofit website. 

 

Your nonprofit’s website is more than just a hub for your online presence—it’s a versatile platform that can help you connect with supporters, amplify your mission, and make a lasting impact. 

 

However, one of its most important functions is as a tool for fundraising. If designed correctly, your website can be an unstoppable force in driving donations. When your website is optimized for online giving, it can make donating a seamless and rewarding experience for your supporters. This is essential because 63% of donors prefer to give online!

 

Below we will explore actionable tips and strategies to help you design or revamp your website to turn it into an effective fundraising powerhouse. Whether you’re looking to inspire first-time donors or make recurring donations easier, these insights will guide you toward creating a site that encourages generosity. 

 

1. Create prominent donation buttons. 

Donation buttons are a critical part of a well-designed nonprofit website. They act as clear calls to action, guiding visitors toward supporting your cause. A strategically placed, well-designed button can simplify the donation process, reduce hesitation, and increase conversion rates. The more prominent and appealing the button, the more likely visitors are to notice it and act.

 

How to Create Effective Donation Buttons 

• Use contrasting colors. Choose colors that stand out from the rest of your website but still align with your branding. For instance, if your site has a neutral color palette, a bright green or orange button can grab attention. High-contrast buttons improve click-through rates because they are easier for users to spot.

• Write clear and action-oriented text. Use direct language that tells users exactly what to do, such as “Donate Now,” “Support Our Mission,” or “Give Today.” Avoid vague terms like “Click Here.” Action-oriented text creates urgency and communicates purpose.

• Place buttons with care. Place donation buttons in high-visibility areas, such as your website header, at the top of your homepage, and near impactful content like success stories or impact videos. Repeat them in the footer and on pages dedicated to your programs. Consistency ensures users can donate no matter where they are on your site.

• Ensure all buttons work and lead to the correct place. Test each button regularly to confirm it works and links directly to your donation form. Broken or misdirected links can frustrate visitors and lead to lost donations. 

 

Regular website maintenance is crucial to ensuring all donation buttons are functional and optimized. Schedule time each month or quarter to conduct a review of your website and make necessary improvements. 

 

2. Simplify the donation process. 

A smooth, quick donation process can significantly increase conversion rates. When potential donors face a complicated or time-consuming form, they’re more likely to abandon the process. By reducing friction and making it as easy as possible for someone to give, you encourage more people to complete their donations.

 

How to Improve Your Online Donation Process 

• Ensure your donation form is user-friendly. The design and functionality of your donation form are key. It should load quickly, be visually appealing, and work seamlessly across all types of devices. Intuitive forms with clear instructions create a positive user experience and encourage completion.

• Only ask for necessary information. Keep the fields to a minimum. For instance, instead of requesting detailed personal information, stick to essentials like name, email, and payment details. The simpler the form, the quicker donors can complete it, reducing drop-offs.

• Keep the form to one page. Avoid making users click through multiple steps to finish their donation. A single-page form keeps the process straightforward and ensures donors aren’t overwhelmed or confused by navigating between pages.

• Test the form before pushing it live. Before launching your form, test it thoroughly to ensure it works flawlessly. Check for broken links, errors, and compatibility issues across different browsers and devices. Simulate user scenarios to confirm that the process is as smooth as possible.

​

3. Provide multiple donation options. 

Donors come from diverse financial backgrounds and have unique preferences when it comes to supporting causes. A one-size-fits-all approach can alienate potential donors who may need options tailored to their giving capacity and circumstances. By offering multiple ways to give, you make it easier for everyone to contribute, increasing donor satisfaction and your chances of securing ongoing support.

 

How to Offer Different Opportunities for Donors 

• Provide suggested giving amounts. Include preset donation amounts, such as $25, $50, or $100, to guide donors and simplify decision-making. Highlight what each amount accomplishes (e.g., “$50 feeds a family for a week”) to create a tangible connection between their contribution and your impact.

• Add the option to give a recurring gift. Allow donors to set up monthly, quarterly, or annual gifts. Recurring donations provide a stable income stream for your nonprofit while making it easier for donors to contribute smaller, manageable amounts over time.

• Enable donors to give in honor or memory of someone. Offer an option for donors to dedicate their gift to a loved one. This personalization adds an emotional element to the donation and creates an opportunity for them to share their contribution with others, further expanding your reach.

• Include multiple payment options. Make it easy for donors to pay by offering a variety of methods, such as debit and credit cards, PayPal, Venmo, Apple Pay, and other digital wallets. The more flexible your payment options, the fewer barriers donors face when contributing.

​

4. Be transparent about how donations will be used. 

Transparency is key to building and maintaining trust with donors. When people understand exactly how their contributions are used, they feel more confident about giving and are more likely to continue supporting your organization over the long term. 

 

Tips for Donation Transparency 

• List current needs or priorities on your donation page. Clearly outline your immediate funding priorities, such as specific programs, campaigns, or goals. For example, detail how a $50 donation supports educational programming or how $100 provides meals for families. This specificity shows donors how their contributions directly address your mission.

• Share financial information on your website. Include access to annual reports, IRS Form 990 filings, or detailed financial summaries. Offering insight into how funds are allocated demonstrates accountability and reassures donors that their money is being used effectively.

• Include elements of social proof. Add donor testimonials, photos, or videos showing how previous contributions have been used. Quotes from past donors about their positive experiences or stories from beneficiaries create a compelling narrative about your impact. This social proof can influence potential donors to trust and contribute.

• Publish an annual impact report. An annual impact report is a powerful tool for showcasing your achievements and financial transparency. Highlight metrics, success stories, and detailed breakdowns of how donations were used to further your mission. Make this report visually engaging and easy to find on your website.

 

Transparency is essential to growing trust amongst your audience. It can be enhanced by sharing impactful donor stories and expressing gratitude. 

5.Leverage matching gifts. 

1. ​

Matching gift programs allow your organization to capitalize on donors’ generosity without requiring them to give more out of pocket. These programs, offered by many employers, will match an employee’s charitable contributions, effectively doubling (or even tripling) the impact of each gift. 

 

Steps to Securing a Matching Gift 

• Educate donors about matching gifts. Make donors aware that many employers offer matching gift programs. Include information about these programs on your website, in email campaigns, and during donation drives. Use phrases like, “Your donation could go twice as far!” to spark interest and encourage participation.

• Embed a matching gift database on your website. Simplify the process by integrating a matching gift database directly into your website. These tools allow donors to quickly check if their employer offers a matching gift program and learn the steps to apply. Many databases also include details on company policies, eligibility requirements, and submission deadlines. 

 

Creating a nonprofit website that drives donations effectively is not just about design—it’s about understanding donor behavior and meeting their needs with intentional features. From compelling calls-to-action and simplified donation processes to flexible giving options and transparent communication, every element plays a role in fostering trust and inspiring generosity. Additionally, leveraging tools like matching gift programs can further amplify the impact of individual contributions.

 

Not only will you enhance the donor experience, but you’ll also cultivate long-term supporters who feel connected to your mission and confident in your stewardship of their contributions.

 

About: Ira Horowitz is an expert in nonprofit online communications and online fundraising. His work has resulted in increased funds and resounding supporter engagement for hundreds of organizations.

​

​